Skip to main content

The Best Thanksgiving Potato Recipes

The best Thanksgiving potatoes? Mashed potatoes may be the consensus opinion around here. But we acknowledge, mashers are not the only potato-based side in the Thanksgiving universe. And there's always room on our Thanksgiving table for cheesy scalloped potatoes or savory potato casseroles. Even a salty serving of golden French fries would be welcome beside our traditional turkey and cranberry sauce. (A drizzle of turkey gravy, who would deny them?)

So yes, there's more than mashers. Let's take a peek at some of our best Thanksgiving potato recipes beginning, naturally, with these special-occasion mashed potatoes!

VIDEO: Chef John's Ultimate Mashed Potatoes

The secret to truly amazing Thanksgiving Day mashed potatoes is, truth be told, not really much of a secret. It’s butter, and lots of it. Tremendous loads of butter. A shocking amount. But this is Thanksgiving dinner, the single most special meal of the year, so maybe we can suspend our health concerns for 24 hours. (We'll be extra good on Black Friday!) For best results, use the good butter -- and bring it down to room temperature. Watch Chef John whip up these once-a-year mashers:

Check out our collection of Mashed Potato Recipes.

Twice Baked Potato Casserole With Bacon

This recipe takes twice-baked potatoes to the next level. Scooped-out baked potatoes, crumbled bacon, sour cream, butter, Cheddar cheese are mashed together, spread into a dish, and topped with additional cheese and bacon. "A slight twist to an old favorite, this cheesy recipe will surely set their mouths to watering," says Tay. "For a creamier casserole, use a potato masher and mash potatoes thoroughly."

Twice Baked Potato Casserole With Bacon

Photo by Rae

Fancy Crusted Rosemary Scalloped Potatoes

"Thin slices of potato are layered around a baking dish to create a beautiful crust for these creamy rosemary potatoes," says Mackenzie Schieck.

Fancy Crusted Rosemary Scalloped Potatoes

Photo by Mackenzie Schieck

Mascarpone Mashed Potatoes

Here's a make-ahead mashed potato recipe featuring creamy mascarpone cheese. Make them in advance, and then simply bake until the tops is beautifully golden brown. "Not only is this a delicious alternative to regular mashed potato recipes, but it's a very user-friendly way to serve your potato side dish," says Chef John. "They're really decadent: not too rich, but just rich enough, and perfect for any special occasion."

Mascarpone Mashed Potatoes

Photo by Lorem Ipsum

Chef John's Potato Roses

You can make these impressive potato roses in advance, too. "They're great for entertaining, since you can make them ahead, and keep them warm in the pan, or cool and reheat in the oven when you are ready to serve," says Chef John. Watch the video to grok Chef John's rose-making technique.

Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes

"It is the sweetness of the roasted garlic that makes these mashed potatoes so delicious," says Angel.

Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Photo by naples34102

Pommes Anna with Gruyere

"Layers of thinly sliced Yukon Gold potatoes, stacked with Gruyere cheese and golden sauteed onions make this French side dish," says Ann.

Pommes Anna with Gruyere

Photo by lutzflcat

Amazing Oven Roasted Potatoes

"With these potatoes, you wont miss the loads of oil in regular fried potatoes," says Shan~Jam. "Golden on the outside, tender on the inside."

Amazing Oven Roasted Potatoes

Photo by naples34102

Basic Mashed Potatoes

Because sometimes basic is best. "If you love good, old fashioned mashed potatoes this is the perfect recipe," says Esmee. "Simple and delicious."

Basic Mashed Potatoes

Photo by lutzflcat

Check out our collection of Thanksgiving Potato Recipes.


Carl Hanson

About Carl Hanson

Carl will eat that. Share with him @CarlNo9 on Twitter.