Skip to main content

10 Best Ways to Get Creative With Brownie Recipes

Not that there's anything wrong with a pan of simple, straightforward homemade brownies, but sometime you just want to go beyond basic. We definitely second that emotion, and offer up 10 of our most creative, over-the-top brownies. Some are made from scratch and some get kickstarted with a box of brownie mix. Either way, these brownies are oh so extra.

1. Caramel Popcorn Brownies

Start with a box of brownie mix (or make your own brownies from scratch), then go to town with popcorn, peanuts, chocolate chips, and peanut butter chips over the top. But that's not all--you'll drizzle homemade caramel sauce over the whole thing before baking.

"Super easy for a potluck dish," says Jenina 'Sutton" Halitsky. She adds, "I used caramel chips instead of making the caramel syrup. Everyone loved this recipe."

2. Chunky Cheesecake Brownies

Homemade brownie dough swirled with a creamy cheesecake layer. Allrecipes homecook dpink13 raves, "This is an excellent recipe! They were excellent warm, and they were just as good the next day. They have the perfect mixture of the sharp cheesecake taste and the sweet brownie taste in a soft, smooth texture."

Chunky Cheesecake Brownies
Photo by chekai

 

3. Red Velvet Cheesecake Swirl Brownies

Another winning combo of brownie and cheesecake, with a red velvet vibe. You might want to save this one in your recipe box for Valentine's Day.

Try these top tips from home cook squeeziebrb:  "Don't use reduced fat or fat free cream cheese. After you have made the swirls, and before you put in oven, VERY gently tap the pan on the counter to remove some bubbles that may have formed when swirling."

4. S'more Brownies

Brownies get layered with marshmallows, chocolate, and graham crackers for this oven-baked take on a classic campfire treat. Warning: All those layers make this very rich and decadent, indeed.

Many reviewers opted to use Teddy Grahams instead of graham cracker pieces, and we say that sounds great!

S'more Brownies
Photo by Dianne

5. Brownie-Mallow Bars

A brownie/crispy rice/marshmallow mash-up! Can you take this much decadence? Maybe you should share. Tiffany did, and says, "This is the second year I've made these to pass out to friends and neighbors during the holidays and I always get such great compliments on them. They are so gooey and delicious, and the crunch from the rice crispy puts it over the top!"

Her top tips: "Under bake by a few minutes so that when you put the marshmallows on top and continue cooking, the brownies won't get too done by the end. Cover the entire brownie mix with the marshmallows because once they're baked you don't want to try and spread or smear them or you'll just get a mess. Really let it cool before pouring the chocolate/peanut butter topping on so the marshmallows won't smear off. Such a good recipe!"

6. Scrumptious Frosted Fudgy Brownies

Homemade brownies are heavenly all on their own, but top them with a thick layer of homemade frosting, and you're at a whole new level.

Allrecipes home cook bellydancer says, "I love these brownies! I have never had such fudgy brownies, or such rich, fudgy frosting. It is very important not to overbake these, or you will lose the fudgy texture. Give these a try, you won't be sorry."

Scrumptious Frosted Fudgy Brownies
Photo by Celeste

 

7. Waffle Iron Brownies

Home made brownie batter meets waffle iron. Deliciousness ensues. Do note they are a more cake-like brownie, so if you prefer chewy brownies, you might want to try the recipe above.

Tiger Didi says, "Just bought a waffle stick maker and was looking for fun recipes to try - you can't believe how good this recipe is in waffle stick form."

waffle iron brownies
Photo by Meredith

8. Caramel Pretzel Brownies

You've got your sweet, your salty, your crunchy, your chocolate, your gooey...all in one bite.

kimba raves, "OMG! These were amazing!! I ended up incorporating mini chocolate chips into the batter before baking instead of on top as directed - only because I misread the recipe. Will definitely make again."

Caramel Pretzel Brownies
Photo by CoOkInGnUt

9. Pumpkin Brownies

Meet your perfect fall brownie. Allrecipes  home cook abapplez says, "Excellent! We love these. Followed the recipe, using canned organic pumpkin, mini chocolate chips and baked them in mini muffin tins. I used a small ice-cream scoop and just layered the two mixtures (did not swirl). The bake time was approx 23 min in my oven. At 18 minutes, I sprinkled additional mini choc chips and chopped walnuts on top and returned to the oven for the last 5 minutes."

She adds, "Perfect, delicious little bites that definitely taste like autumn. By not swirling the two batters together, I think the pumpkin flavor really came through."

10. Coconut Macaroon Brownies

A rich layer of coconut macaroon is layered between home made chocolate brownies, and there goes your will power. Some reviewers use unsweetened coconut, and some use sweetened. What you choose to do is between you and your sweet tooth.

If this is your jam, you might like more ideas for stuffed brownies.

coconut macaroon brownies
Photo by footballgrl16

 

You might also like 11 outrageous snacks to make with boxed brownie mix.

 

Vanessa Greaves

About Vanessa Greaves

Good food, friends, and fun are always on the menu. Find me as foodelicious on Allrecipes and vanny.gee on Instagram (but only if you don't mind cat pics and cocktails).