Skip to main content

9 Amazing Candy Bar Copycat Cookies That Taste Like the Real Thing

When you can't decide between a candy bar and a cookie (#firstworldproblems) you can have the best of both all in one. These cookies are copycats of popular candy bars, with the added bonus of being extra good because they're homemade.

1. Crunch Bar

"Very, very yummy. Taste just like a Heath Bar. Not for the weight consious though, but excellent. — MRS. WAGS

 

Crunch Bar

Photo by Molly

2. Mound Bars

"They were SO good! My second batch I topped with sliced almonds and made them Almond Joy Bars." — Lady Di

 

Mound Bars

Photo by Allrecipes Magazine

3. Peanut Butter Bars I

"Kids said that these are better than Reese's!" — Jennifer C.

 

Peanut Butter Bars I

Photo by L.P.L.

4. Kitty Kat Bars

"To make these taste more like Kit Kats, I leave out the butterscotch chips and sub milk chocolate chips." — MAGGIE MCGUIRE

 

Kitty Kat Bars

Photo by mominml

5. Clark Bars

"Very good. Very easy. Will definitely make again." (I used milk chocolate chips.) — peachypie

 

Clark Bars

Photo by Molly

6. Babe Ruth Bars II

"I recommend only covering them in a high quality chocolate (no chips mixed in)I used a higher grade dark chocolate. These are truly awesome!" — Maureen

 

Babe Ruth Bars II

Photo by mauigirl

7. Peanut Candy Bar Cake

"Yes, this is quite good! My husband said it tasted like a soft Payday candy bar." — PULLEYHEATHER

 

Peanut Candy Bar Cake Photo

Photo by JESSIE6381

8. Mock Butterfinger®

"My mother-in-law makes a similar cookie using Ritz crackers. It's crazy how similar they taste to real Butterfingers." — NWMama

 

Mock Butterfinger

Photo by sonjagroset

9. Snappy Turtle Cookies

Just like those gooey caramel/chocolate/pecans candies that scare the bejeebers out of your dentist.

 

Snappy Turtle Cookies

Photo by Holiday Baker


Related Deliciousness

5 Girl Scout Cookie Copycats to Tide You Over Until Next Year
Favorite Copycat Starbucks Bakery Treats
4 Super Cute Copycat Snack Cakes
8 Quick Cookies Anyone Can Make
More Top-Rated Cookie Recipes


Love dessert? (What a question.) Get more sweet inspiration on Allrecipes Sweet Spot.


About Vanessa Greaves

Good food, friends, and fun are always on the menu. Find me as foodelicious on Allrecipes and vanny.gee on Instagram (but only if you don't mind cat pics and cocktails).