Skip to main content

9 Valentine's Day Sweets Better Than a Box of Chocolates

Red Velvet Cookies
Red Velvet Cookies | Photo by footballgrl16

If the way to someone’s heart is through their stomach, these treats are just what our hearts want.

Feelings of love and adoration run rampant on Valentine’s Day—as do candy hearts, pink and red lollipops, and countless other sugary confections. Homemade sweets are a wonderful way to show your love to everyone in your life on the day of hearts. The recipes on this list are not only fun but also tell your valentines that your heart beats for them.

1. Stained-glass Sugar Hearts

Melting hard candies between sugar cookie cut-outs turns them into art you can eat. For a fun mix of shapes, you can use other cookie cutters beyond the Valentine’s Day heart. Crush up and melt other colors of hard candy for a fun twist, too. These will be a standout among the many Valentine’s cookies.

Stained-glass Sugar Hearts
Photo by the4taals

2. Easy OREO Truffles

Three magical words and three magical ingredients. Just wait until you present this tray of chocolate cookie truffles to your loved ones. Their hearts will grow three sizes in just one bite.

Easy OREO Truffles
Photo by Sandra1980

3. Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Chocolate-covered strawberries are a classic Valentine’s Day treat, but there’s a bit of magic to getting the crispy shell on each juicy berry bite smooth and beautiful. This recipe makes quick work of that task, and the drizzle of white chocolate adds a little pizzazz.

Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Photo by Paleosue

4. Chantal’s New York Cheesecake

There are cookie people. There are cake people. Then, there are cheesecake people, those who will never pass up a slice, their hearts softening as the creamy confection melts in their mouths. Make the classic New York-style cheesecake worthy of a Valentine’s Day dinner or gathering with a beautiful display of strawberries on top. You could also take it one step further with an assortment of chocolate-dipped fruits for an ultrarich treat.

Chantal’s New York Cheesecake
Photo by Grish B-Del

5. Red Velvet Cookies

If you love the classic red velvet cake, you’ll adore these cookies. They’re fluffy and light, but they make the perfect sandwich to cream cheese frosting. “This recipe is AWESOME,” writes Allrecipes user samiah. “The consistency of the ‘cookie’ is the perfect balance of red velvet cake moist-ness but the thicker texture of a soft cookie.”

6. Heart Cookies Decorated with Royal Icing

There’s nothing more beautiful than delicate sugar cookies dressed with shiny royal icing. For Valentine’s Day, you can really let your creative icing skills show, too. Bring the kids in to help you decorate. The littlest ones might not want to squeeze the icing onto the cookies, but they’ll be happy to toss on plenty of shiny sprinkles.

Heart Cookies Decorated with Royal Icing
Photo by Allrecipes

7. Cinnamon Heart Popcorn

Pink popcorn is the perfect poppable treat for the people you love. Melting red-hot candies coats the kernels with a bright pink hue and adds a kick of spice. You can bag these up for classroom treats, too.

Cinnamon Heart Popcorn
Photo by cheesecakelover

8. Death by Chocolate III

Now you’re just showing off. There’s nothing pink or heart-shaped about this layered trifle, but be prepared to have everyone confess their love to you. The best part? It’s quite easy to make, using a brownie mix and convenience options like chocolate-covered toffee bars and instant pudding mix.

Death by Chocolate III
Photo by Allrecipes

9. Cosmo-Style Pomegranate Martini

For Galentine’s Day, ply your friends with fun martinis. This one features bright citron vodka with a bit of sweet-tart pomegranate juice. They’ll make everyone feel warm and fuzzy and keep the shaker going all night.

Cosmo-Style Pomegranate Martini
Photo by Wyattdogster

Check out our collection of Valentine's Day Recipes.


Related:

Kimberly Holland

About Kimberly Holland

Kimberly's favorite hobby is grocery shopping. Her second favorite hobby is realizing she already had two of the foods she just bought. Will bake. Won't grill. Can caramel. Find her at khollandcooks on Instagram and on Allrecipes.