Skip to main content

How to Host a Festive Holiday Pie Party

Pie Party

Holiday Pie Party | Photo by Mackenzie Schieck

Who wants homemade pie?The answer is everyone! But not everyone has the time or inclination to make all the homemade pies they crave. The solution? Host a holiday pie party! Think of it like a pie potluck, where having lots of leftovers to take home is the goal. (Oh, the pie-for-breakfast possibilities!)

I'll share easy tips to host a festive holiday pie party, as well as suggest favorite recipes to in case someone needs some ins-pie-ration.

Party it Up, Pie-Style

More pie, anyone? More pie, everyone! Here are a few tips for how to plan a holiday pie party that'll leave guests feeling full and happy.

  • Know who's bringing what. When you send invites, either have people sign up for the type of pie they'd like to make and bring (use an online list that auto-updates), or assign guests a certain pie—let them know they are welcome to swap with other guests if they like. For more popular pies like apple and pumpkin, consider having more than one person bring these types to be sure there's enough to go around. Also, have guests print out their recipes to share, and bring a knife and pie server for their own pie.
  • Build a buffet for display. Make sure you have a space that's big enough for all the pies that will be walked through the front door. For especially large guest lists, a table that can be accessed on all sides is ideal. Conduct a pre-party plate and mug/cup inventory—do you have enough in your cupboards to cover the whole crowd? Fill in the gaps with loaners or recyclable paper versions.
  • What goes with pie? Also, think about what you'd like to accompany the pies: whipped cream and ice cream for topping, coffee, tea, spiced cider, or eggnog for sipping. You might also want to have a few savory appetizers on hand to balance out all the sweetness.
  • Have a take-away plan. Ask guests to bring empty containers they can use to take home slices at the end of the night. It's also a good idea to have some extras on hand in case someone forgets. You can pick up stacks of inexpensive aluminum pie dishes (with or without handy covers) online or in the baking aisle of most grocery stores.

10 Crowd-Pleasing Pie Recipes

Here's a round-up of some of our most popular pies, which are sure to disappear quickly.

1. Apple Pie by Grandma Ople

This recipe has five stars for very good reason, according to wee red: "Believe the hype. I made this for the first time for a dinner party I had last week, and it did not disappoint."

apple pie by grandma ople
Photo by Holiday Baker

 

2. Mrs. Sigg's Fresh Pumpkin Pie

Recipe submitter, Beth Sigworth, explains that using fresh pumpkin gives a pie the best flavor and texture. And the recipe's 5-star rating seems to confirm that point!

Before you get started, check out these easy tips for baking with fresh pumpkin—including what kind of pumpkin tastes best.

3. Sweet Potato Pie I

Even first-time pie bakers can pull this one off. JMLATHAM says, "This is the first pie I've ever made and it came out fantastic!"

Sweet Potato Pie I
Photo by Mackenzie Schieck

 

4. Irresistible Pecan Pie

Recipe creator, IHART44 promises once you start eating this pie, you won't be able to stop—so, fair warning! And a couple of tips from home cooks: A number of reviewers recommended adding vanilla to the crust and cinnamon to the filling if you want to bump up the flavor.

Irresistible Pecan Pie
Photo by Allrecipes

 

5. Grandma's Lemon Meringue Pie

Allrecipes homecook, AUDREY25, says this recipe is "nice and lemony, not too sweet, and with good proportions of curd and meringue." Sold!

New to making meringue? Here's how to make perfect meringues for pies, cookies, and more.

Grandma's lemon Meringue Pie
Photo by Dianne

 

6. Peanut Butter Pie

This easy refrigerator pie calls for just a handful of ingredients and comes together in minutes—the hardest part will be waiting the two hours it needs to chill in the fridge. (You can do it.)

peanut butter pie
Photo by Mackenzie Schieck

 

7. Crustless Cranberry Pie

Some reviewers described this pie as a giant scone, and some as as cake-like—and pretty much everyone called it absolutely delicious. BUBINK says, "Totally easy to put together and totally tasty! Served this with vanilla ice cream and it was a major hit!"

crustless cranberry pie
Photo by Blair Blanks

 

8. Dutch Apple Pie with Oatmeal Streusel

"The crunchy oat topping adds an extra dimension to this delicious apple pie," says this recipe's creator, Ginny. She recommends using Golden Delicious, Jonagold, or Granny Smith apples.

dutch apple pie with oatmeal streusel
Photo by Sara Maximoff

 

9. French Silk Chocolate Pie I

This smooth, creamy pie calls for just a few simple ingredients—melted chocolate being one (chocoholics rejoice!)—and only takes 20 minutes to prepare. Plan for two hours of chilling time, though. And no sneaking a taste! (Okay, yes sneaking a taste.)

french silk chocolate pie
Photo by Mackenzie Schieck

 

10. Coconut Cream Pie

Recipe reviewer KRISTINE says she likes this recipe because it produces a bigger pie, making it a great option for a pie party. Plus, it's a big hit: "My family (especially my dad!) just loves it," she says.

Coconut Cream Pie
Photo by Thealey

Need a pie crust recipe? This Butter Flakey Pie Crust is one of our most popular recipes, and this Gluten-Free Pie Crust is a 5-star winner. Check out our entire collection of pie crust recipes, and if you need to brush up your skills, here are step-by-step instructions for making pie crust.

More Holiday Party Inspiration

3 DIY Bar Holiday Party Ideas
Small Bites for Your Holiday Party
Host a Cookie Exchange Party

About Mackenzie Schieck

Writer and photographer obsessed with lattes, Mexican food, and stuff that’s funny.