Skip to main content

How to Make Deviled Eggs Ahead of Time

With everything else you're making for your Easter lunch, Memorial Day, 4th of July celebration, weekend picnics, potlucks, or other get-togethers, you can give yourself a helping hand by making deviled eggs in advance—at least several of the steps. Here's how.

Classic Savory Deviled Eggs
Pictured: Classic Savory Deviled Eggs | Photo by naples34102

How to Make Deviled Eggs Ahead of Time

Related: 12 Best Deviled Egg Ideas from Classic to Creative

If you are responsible for bringing deviled eggs, you can give yourself a head start with these tips:

  1. Boil the eggs up to 48 hours in advance. Peel, cut in half, and remove yolks. Place egg whites on tray, cover with plastic wrap, and store in fridge.
  2. Make yolk mixture according to recipe. Fill a zip-top bag or reusable piping bag with the yolk mixture. Seal the bag, removing as much air as possible, and store in the fridge.
  3. Just before you're ready to serve, take the tray of egg whites and the yolk mixture from fridge. Gently knead the yolk mixture to recombine and warm it up slightly. (Cold filling won't pipe as well.)
  4. Clip a small piece from the corner of the plastic bag. Pipe the yolk mixture into each egg white. Garnish, and serve.

If you don't want to be piping as guests walk in your door, you can pipe ahead. Deviled eggs will stay in good shape—that is, the yolk mixture is unlikely to turn watery — for up to six hours if stored in the fridge. Pipe, garnish, cover, and chill to check the eggs off your list.

Related: Get tips to make the best deviled eggs.

How to Safely Transport Deviled Eggs

On their slippery curved whites, deviled eggs move easily — and swiftly — around plates when jostled. A car — and all the bumpy roads — can turn your perfectly piped eggs into a splatter painting-inspired mess. These four ideas can help ensure your deviled eggs arrive safely at their final destination:

  1. Mini muffin tins: Pop each egg half into the well of a mini muffin tin — some larger ones have 24 spots — and cover with plastic wrap.
  2. Ice cube tray: Nuzzle each egg half into an ice cube spot. Cover with plastic wrap, and place in a box top or casserole carrier if you have more than one.
  3. Deviled egg carrier: You can buy a deviled egg carrier for less than $10. These handy trays are great when you want to make deviled eggs in advance and when you need to take them somewhere.
  4. Assemble at destination: If you'll have the counterspace and time, hold off filling the egg whites and garnishing them until you're at your final stop. All you need to do once you arrive is snip the end of the bag, pipe in the yolk, and garnish. This way, your perfect deviled eggs are presentable and you spare yourself some worry.

Best Garnishes for Make-Ahead Deviled Eggs

Garnishes are to deviled eggs what cherries are to ice cream sundaes: Without one, the dish just isn't complete. But if you're making your deviled eggs ahead of time and storing or transporting them, you've got to consider the impact the extra moisture exposure will have on the garnish. In short, some garnishes will be soggy — and that's no good.

Here are some of the best garnishes for deviled eggs when you plan to make ahead:

  • celery
  • carrot
  • raw onion
  • jalapeno
  • paprika
  • red pepper
  • radishes

Anything that isn't good without the crunch — bacon, nuts, crispy onions — as well as fresh herbs should wait until just before the eggs are served for the best texture and flavor.

Check out our collection of Deviled Egg Recipes.

Kimberly Holland

About Kimberly Holland

Kimberly's favorite hobby is grocery shopping. Her second favorite hobby is realizing she already had two of the foods she just bought. Will bake. Won't grill. Can caramel. Find her at khollandcooks on Instagram and on Allrecipes.