Skip to main content

Try These 14 Top-Rated Creamy Dressings on Your Salad Greens

It's an amazing time to be a salad lover, with ever-expanding options available in the packaged greens section of supermarket's produce department. Since discovering the amazing Organic Girl's Butter-Plus Lettuce Mix, I've upped the amount of greens on my breakfast, lunch and dinner plate. Yes, I eat salad for breakfast. This exercise has also been an awesome excuse to hone my homemade salad dressing skills. Here are great creamy salad dressings that rose to the top of the list of creamy/dreamy ways to make those wonderfully tender greens shine extra brightly.

Chef John's Ranch Dressing

Sour cream and buttermilk give this version a one-two tangy punch, while the fresh Italian parsley adds a fresh note. Debi T., says: "So easy to make and so good -- I'll never buy jarred or bottled ranch dressing again!"

Chef John's Ranch Dressing

Photo by Allrecipes Magazine

More: Avocado Ranch Dressing and Jalapeno Ranch Dressing.

The Best Caesar Salad Dressing

While romaine lettuce is the traditional choice for this classic salad, this citrus-y, creamy dressing proves its versatility. Tweaks from reviewers include skipping the egg substitute and using fish sauce instead of anchovy paste. (Good call!)

Caesar Salad Supreme

Photo by Allrecipes Magazine

More: Ingrid's Caesar Dressing and John G's Caesar Dressing.

Chef John's Green Goddess

Surprise! There's a little anchovy in this beloved dressing, but it's so subtle, you're not likely to taste it among all the fresh herbs, garlic and lemon juice.

More: Creamy Greek Dressing, Green Goddess Chive Dressing and Avocado Green Goddess.

Chef John's Blue Cheese Dressing

The brilliant twist in this genius recipe is using a frozen chunk of blue cheese for shredding. This technique ensures more of the tart cheese is mixed throughout the batch, which definitely won't last long if you have blue cheese fans in the house.

More: Roasted Garlic Blue Cheese, Roquefort Dressing II and Bill's Blue Cheese.

Looking for more inspiration?

About Leslie Kelly

Always hungry to learn, never had my fill of oysters, Memphis dry rub ribs, wild salmon, chocolate chip cookies or a well-rolled lumpia. Washington state wine lover, bourbon fan. Totally obsessed with brunch!